How to Benchmark Marketing

If you’re not benchmarking your marketing, you’re basically guessing—and guessing is expensive.

Marketing without benchmarks is like launching a website and hoping it “just works.” Sure, you might get lucky. But more often than not, you’re leaving growth, traffic, and revenue on the table.

With the help of the digital marketing experts at Lifted Logic, you can figure out how to benchmark your marketing. And you can do it in a way that identifies strengths and weaknesses, improves ROI, and helps your team get sh*t done efficiently 👍

Keep reading this guide to explore how to take your efforts from marketing that just exists to marketing that performs, starting with benchmarking.

What Is Marketing Benchmarking?

You might think marketing benchmarking sounds fancy, but it’s actually pretty simple. It’s the process of measuring your marketing performance metrics against a standard. (Either your own past results or what others in your industry are doing.)

You might start looking at things like engagement, conversion rates, or growth. Essentially, marketing benchmarking helps you figure out if marketing is actually working … or if you’re just hoping it is 😀

If you’re thinking, “No way this makes that big of a difference,” we understand. In fact, many businesses skip this step because it takes time, consistency, and a willingness to accept setbacks and shortcomings.

It’s way easier to say “traffic is up” or “engagement feels better” than it is to dig into what those metrics mean. Without these specific benchmarks, you don’t have context on what has improved and, more importantly, why.

Internal vs. External Benchmarks

When thinking about how to benchmark your marketing, you should understand the 2 types of benchmarks. When it comes to assessing the overall success of your marketing, we look at internal and external benchmarks. The real magic happens when you combine both to make data-backed decisions.

Internal benchmarks compare your current performance to your past performance. Think month-over-month traffic, year-over-year conversions, or campaign-to-campaign results. These tell you if you’re trending in the right direction, based on your business’s personal growth.

External benchmarks, on the other hand, compare your performance to industry standards or competitors. This is where you find out if your “good” is actually good—or just average 😌

Here’s an example: you see a 10% increase in leads to your e-commerce site. Your first thought might be, “This is great!”—and it might be. But without benchmarks, there’s no way to know if that growth is actually strong, or if others in your space are growing faster.

The Benchmarks That Matter & What They Mean

If you’ve ever looked into how to benchmark marketing, you’ve probably run into a wall of conflicting data, vague averages, and charts. All of which somehow say everything (and nothing) at the same time.

So let’s simplify it.

Benchmarking isn’t about chasing someone else’s numbers; it’s about understanding what healthy performance looks like so you can make smarter decisions for your company. Think of it less like a scoreboard and more like a diagnostic tool.

Good marketing isn’t guesswork. It’s measured. Using channel-specific digital marketing KPIs tells you if your efforts perform well and where you might need to put some extra attention.

Channel-By-Channel KPIs: SEO, PPC, Email, and Social Media

Not all channels follow the same rules. Comparing SEO to PPC is like comparing a marathon to a sprint. Each channel has a unique job and matters for a specific reason.

🌐SEO (Organic Search): Long-Term Momentum

Often your longest marketing effort, search engine optimization (SEO), builds momentum that compounds over time. It’s your foundation that delivers consistent, high-intent traffic—and when it works, it really works.

SEO connects you with audiences that are actively searching for what you offer. It’s a powerful tool when used well, and with the right expectations. When SEO works properly, you can see steady growth not just in traffic, but in qualified visitors that convert.

If you’re learning how to benchmark marketing, start here:

• Organic traffic growth (month-over-month and year-over-year)
• Keyword rankings for high-intent searches
• Conversion rate from organic visitors

Most sites see conversion rates around 2–5%, depending on industry, but execution matters more than averages.

Cost per lead from SEO is typically lower over time ($30–$90) compared to paid channels, since you’re not paying for every click.

Expect gradual traffic growth over 3–12 months. Not instant. Not flashy. Just consistent, qualified traffic that actually converts.

💰PPC (Paid Search): Immediate Visibility

To reach the right audience immediately, pay-per-click (PPC) works best. While SEO is a long game, PPC gets you in front of people right now.

With the right strategy, testing, and optimization (something our team does daily), PPC becomes a reliable, scalable driver of leads and revenue. PPC isn’t just about getting clicks—it’s about getting the right clicks.

What to benchmark:

• Cost per lead (CPL)
• Conversion rate (typically 5–10%)
• Return on ad spend (ROAS)

Cost per lead for PPC can vary widely ($70–$300+, depending on the industry), so context matters. A higher CPL isn’t a problem if those leads actually convert.

Cost per lead is important—but it’s only half the story. What really matters is what those leads turn into. That’s where ROI comes in.

Here’s a quick guide on how to measure marketing ROI:

ROI = (Revenue – Marketing Cost) ÷ Marketing Cost

If you’re making more money than you’re spending—and can do it consistently—you’re in a good spot.

Most businesses aim for at least a 3:1 return (meaning $3 earned for every $1 spent). Anything higher? Even better. But context matters.

A lower ROI might still be strong if you’re scaling quickly. A higher ROI might mean you’re playing it too safe and leaving growth on the table.

📧Email Marketing: Turning Interest Into Action

When you’re learning how to benchmark marketing, email is one of the clearest places to measure impact—because the intent is already there.

Instead of focusing on new traffic, email marketing converts and nurtures the audience you already have, making it an incredibly valuable asset. They’ve opted in or engaged in some way before. That puts them a whole lot closer to making a decision.

With the right messaging, design, and segmentation, emails make a consistent conversion channel.

What to benchmark for email marketing:

• Open rate (are people actually seeing your emails?)
• Click-through rate (are they interested enough to engage?)
• Conversion rate (are they taking action?)

Typical conversion rates land around 5–7%, but like everything else, execution matters. The more relevant your messaging, the better your results.

📷Social Media: Awareness and Engagement

Social media is where you let your brand shine ✨ This channel showcases your brand, often being one of the first impressions your audience has to connect with you.

It’s not always where people convert. But, if you build familiarity, connect with your audience and other brands, and stay relevant, you ‘ll find that people stick around for a while.

Pair that with high-quality photo and video (shameless plug: our media team knows what they’re doing), and you’ve got a visual experience people can actually trust 😉

What to benchmark:

• Engagement (likes, comments, shares)
• Click-through rate
• Assisted conversions (how social supports other channels)

Strong social performance isn’t just about numbers—it’s about momentum. Keep showing up, keep engaging, and your audience will too.

How to Set Your Benchmarks

Now that we’ve discussed how to benchmark your marketing channels, let’s look at how to actually set these guidelines without guessing.

Step 1: Audit Your Current Performance

Before you look outward, look inward.

You need a clear understanding of where you are before deciding where you should be. That means pulling real data from your existing channels—not rough estimates, not “it feels like it’s doing okay.”

Look at:

• Traffic (by channel)
• Conversion rates
• Cost per lead
• Engagement metrics

This signifies your starting point. And if the numbers aren’t great, that’s where the opportunity lies 📈

Step 2: Research Industry Averages

Now we begin to look outward. Marketing benchmarks by industry averages give you context, helping you explore if you’re on target … or way off.

Different industries, budgets, locations, and strategies all impact performance. What works for a family-owned, local coffee shop probably isn’t going to map perfectly to a regional coffee chain. Keep in mind these averages are references meant to help you grow, not a rulebook.

Use benchmarks to:

• Validate performance
• Identify gaps
• Spot opportunities for improvement

Step 3: Set Realistic Targets (Not Aspirational)

It’s tempting to jump from a 2% conversion rate to a 10% goal because … why not aim high, right? When learning how to benchmark marketing, remember that unrealistic goals don’t motivate—and they can actually stall progress.

Instead, try building targets based on:

• Your current performance
• Historical trends
• What’s actually achievable with your resources

Also, think incremental improvements:

• Increase conversion rate from 2% → 3%
• Reduce CPL by 15–20%
• Grow traffic steadily month-over-month

Small, consistent gains beat big, unrealistic leaps every time.

Step 4: Build a Measurement Cadence

When figuring out how to benchmark your marketing, remember this: benchmarks only work if you actually pay attention to them.

Setting them and walking away is like planting seeds and never watering them. (Not exactly a winning strategy.) Instead, you need to check in, make adjustments, and track progress over time.

The same goes for your marketing benchmarks. Build a consistent cadence for reviewing performance and refining your strategy. That’s how you can spot what needs attention—and what’s actually worth celebrating.

Here’s a simple structure to follow:

• Weekly: quick performance checks (PPC, traffic trends)
• Monthly: deeper analysis (conversions, CPL, engagement)
• Quarterly: strategic adjustments (budget, channel focus, campaigns)

Need Help Setting Your Benchmarks? Let’s Talk.

We get it—digging into the nitty-gritty of your marketing can feel like a lot. But that’s kind of our thing 😆

If you’re not sure what you should be tracking or how to benchmark your marketing, we’ll help you make sense of it—no guesswork, no fluff. Just clear, actionable insights you can actually use.

Contact Us

Now, let’s talk about the tools we love using to help see the power in benchmarking.

Tools for Tracking, Not Guessing

If benchmarking is the peanut butter, these tools are the jelly. They help connect the “what” to the “how.” You don’t need every tool under the sun, just ones with the right setup and accessibility.

The best tool is the one you understand (and use). Here’s where to start.

Google Analytics 4 & Google Search Console (GSC)

This is where you can see the bones of your site. Your “what’s actually happening on our website?” metrics.

Google Analytics 4 tracks how users interact with your site: where they come from, what they do, and whether they convert.

Google Search Console shows how your site performs in search: what keywords you rank for, how often you appear, and what people click.

Together, these tools give you visibility into both traffic and intent. One shows behavior. The other shows how people find you.

SEMRush & Ahrefs

When you want to learn how your business stacks up against your competitors, SEMRush and Ahrefs are where it’s at. Both of these platforms help you track keyword rankings, analyze competitors, and uncover opportunities you might be missing.

They don’t just show performance; they give you context. You can see what’s working in your industry, what people want more of, and where you can realistically compete.

Platform-Native Analytics (Social & Email)

Every platform you use—whether it’s social media or email—comes with built-in analytics. And they’re more powerful than most people realize.

Think:

• Social platforms (engagement, reach, clicks)
• Email platforms (opens, clicks, conversions)

This is where you measure channel-specific performance. The metrics here tell you how your content is landing and what your audience actually cares about.

⭐Bonus: it’s real-time. No waiting, no lag, just immediate feedback.

Dashboard Tools: Looker Studio & Databox

If you’re tired of jumping between 5 platforms and 12 tabs, you’re not the only one.

If you’re wondering how to benchmark your marketing and see all of your data in one spot, that’s where dashboards come in. Looker Studio (formerly Google Data Studio) and Databox pull your data into one place, so you can actually see what’s going on.

These platforms centralize data from many tools into real-time visual reports (tables, graphs, and charts). Dashboards turn scattered data into clear insights.

Common Mistakes With Benchmarking

Most issues don’t come from bad data. They come from how that data is used (or misunderstood). If looking at your benchmarks feels confusing, discouraging, or just plain wrong, there’s a good chance one of the following things is happening.

Comparing Yourself to Companies 10x Your Size

When learning how to benchmark marketing, it’s tempting to look at big-name brands and think, “That’s where we should be.” Not always.

Larger companies have bigger budgets, larger teams, and way more data to work with. Benchmark against what’s realistic for your business, not someone else’s highlight reel.

Ignoring Seasonality

You’ll come to learn that not all traffic trends are created equal. Depending on your industry, demand can shift dramatically throughout the year. If you’re only looking at month-to-month data without context, you might think something’s broken—when it’s actually just seasonality doing its thing.

Take HVAC, for example. Business heats up fast in the summer (literally), slows down in the shoulder seasons, then spikes again when temperatures drop.

What to do instead:

• Compare year-over-year performance
• Look for patterns over time
• Factor in known busy and slow seasons

Measuring Vanity Metrics

We all love a good-looking report. Big numbers. Upward trends. Lots of green arrows ✅

High traffic, tons of impressions, and growing follower counts can be great. But if they’re not leading to conversions or revenue? They’re just noise.

Focus on metrics that tie back to business outcomes. Think:

• Conversions
• Cost per lead
• Revenue impact

Not Adjusting Benchmarks Quarterly

Setting benchmarks once and never revisiting them is like setting a GPS and refusing to reroute when roads close. Markets change. Strategies evolve. Performance improves (hopefully).

When learning how to benchmark your marketing, your benchmarks should reflect that.

Best practice:

• Review performance monthly
• Adjust benchmarks quarterly
• Re-align goals based on real data

Benchmarks should grow with you, not hold you back.

When to Call in an Agency

There’s a point where internal teams hit a wall. Not because they’re not capable, but because they’re too close to the work, stretched thin, or just missing the right perspective.

That’s where bringing in outside expertise starts to make a lot of sense.

If you fall into any of these categories, give our experts a call:

• You’re tracking data, but not sure what to do with it
• Your performance has plateaued (or declined) without a clear reason
• You’re relying on guesswork more than strategy
• You don’t have a consistent benchmarking or reporting cadence

What a Benchmarking Audit Looks Like at Lifted Logic

At Lifted Logic, we don’t just glance at your numbers and call it a day. We dig in.

We look at:

• Channel performance (SEO, PPC, email, social)
• Conversion paths and user behavior
• Cost-efficiency and lead quality
• Opportunities for quick wins and long-term growth

Then we connect the dots.

You don’t just get numbers—you get clarity, direction, and a plan.

Let’s Make Your Data Work for You

If your benchmarks are off, your strategy feels stuck, or your team just needs a fresh perspective, it might be time to bring in some backup.

If you’re wondering how to benchmark your marketing in a way that fits your business, your goals, and your toolkit, let our marketing wizards show you the way.

Take the next step and get a free marketing audit by contacting our team.

Contact Us